Itachi would likely win against Naruto, especially during the earlier stages of Naruto's development. The reference indicates Itachi's Mangekyou Sharingan gives him a significant advantage, potentially even allowing him to control powerful beings like Kurama (the Nine-Tailed Fox) given his genjutsu prowess, though that's debatable as Kurama is significantly more powerful now and has help resisting genjutsu.
However, the outcome is heavily dependent on when the fight takes place in the Naruto timeline. Here's a breakdown considering different scenarios:
-
Early Naruto vs. Itachi: Itachi wins easily. Naruto's early skillset is no match for Itachi's genjutsu, ninjutsu, and overall battle intelligence.
-
Shippuden (Early) Naruto vs. Itachi: Itachi still likely wins. While Naruto's Rasengan and developing control over Kurama's chakra are considerable, Itachi's strategic mind, Sharingan abilities (including Tsukuyomi and Amaterasu), and Susanoo provide a significant edge. Itachi was also holding back during his fight with Sasuke, and the true extent of his abilities is unknown.
-
Shippuden (Late) Naruto (Pain Arc) vs. Itachi (Alive): This is a much closer fight. Naruto has mastered Sage Mode and defeated Pain. Itachi, even with his prowess, is weakened by his illness. The outcome depends on the specific circumstances and strategy employed by both. Many would still favor Itachi due to his incredible intelligence and Sharingan abilities, but Naruto's raw power is closing the gap.
-
End of Series Naruto (Hokage) vs. Reanimated Itachi: Naruto wins decisively. As Hokage, Naruto possesses immense power exceeding even his Sage of Six Paths mode from the war arc, vastly surpassing anything Itachi could contend with, particularly given Itachi's reanimated state has limitations.
Key Factors Influencing the Fight:
- Itachi's Genjutsu: Itachi's genjutsu, especially Tsukuyomi, is a potent weapon. However, Naruto's connection to Kurama provides a defense against genjutsu to some extent.
- Naruto's Rasengan and Rasenshuriken: Powerful offensive techniques, but Itachi is skilled at evasion and counter-attack.
- Itachi's Susanoo: A nearly impenetrable defense and powerful offense. It can only be broken by equal power or great hax.
- Naruto's Sage Mode: Grants enhanced strength, speed, and sensory abilities.
- Kurama's Chakra: Provides Naruto with enormous chakra reserves and the potential for powerful attacks. Naruto eventually masters the use of Kurama's chakra.
- Itachi's Intelligence: Itachi is one of the most intelligent characters in the series. This allows him to analyze his opponents and formulate effective strategies.
Conclusion:
While earlier versions of Naruto would certainly lose, a fully realized Hokage Naruto would undoubtedly defeat Itachi. Earlier scenarios are heavily in Itachi's favor due to his mastery of the Sharingan and strategic abilities.
