Aerith's feelings are complex, but evidence suggests she develops stronger feelings for Cloud than she retained for Zack, though her initial connection to Cloud stems from his resemblance to Zack.
Aerith's Feelings for Zack
- Past Love: Aerith loved Zack in the past. He was her first love, and their relationship was significant for her. The Crisis Core: Final Fantasy VII game depicts the depth of their bond.
- Past Tense: Dialogue within Final Fantasy VII (both original and Remake) subtly indicates that while she did love Zack, those feelings are largely in the past.
- Idealized Image: Some interpretations suggest Aerith may have idealized Zack, particularly due to the circumstances of their relationship.
Aerith's Feelings for Cloud
- Initial Attraction: Aerith is initially drawn to Cloud because of his resemblance to Zack. She recognizes a familiarity that sparks her interest.
- Growing Affection: As the story progresses, Aerith's feelings for Cloud become deeper and more complex than just a reflection of her feelings for Zack. She gets to know Cloud as an individual and develops a genuine connection with him.
- Unique Bond: Their shared journey, their connection to the Lifestream, and the shared dangers they face forge a unique bond between Aerith and Cloud that goes beyond her past with Zack.
- "Wasn't serious": In the original FFVII, Aerith explicitly states her relationship with Zack "wasn't serious" when Cloud asks about her boyfriend. This suggests a level of emotional detachment from that relationship.
Conclusion
While Zack was Aerith's first love and held a special place in her heart, her feelings for Cloud evolve into something deeper and more meaningful. Her relationship with Cloud is based on genuine connection and understanding, suggesting a stronger affection for Cloud than what remains for Zack. She is in love with the real Cloud, not just Zack's image.
