Based on the provided reference, Harry Potter 1 (and the series) is generally considered inappropriate for most children, particularly those whose moral formation is not yet well established.
According to the perspective offered, while the movie contains fantasy and magic elements, it lacks the clear moral framework found in works like Tolkien's. The reference explicitly states that the Harry Potter series is inappropriate for minors who are not already WELL formed morally and is inappropriate for most.
Why This Perspective Recommends Caution
The core concern highlighted by the reference is the moral messaging within the series. Unlike stories perceived to have clear lines between good and evil or a defined spiritual dominion, the Harry Potter universe is seen as having a more ambiguous moral landscape, which could be confusing or negatively influential for developing minds.
Considerations for Parents
When deciding if Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone (or Philosopher's Stone) is suitable for your child, consider the following points based on this viewpoint:
- Moral Development: The reference places significant emphasis on a child's existing moral foundation. If a child is young and still forming their understanding of right and wrong, this perspective suggests caution.
- Complexity of Themes: While the first movie is arguably the least dark in the series, it still introduces themes of death, good vs. evil, and moral choices that might be presented in a way the reference finds problematic for young viewers.
- Comparison to Other Fantasy: The reference draws a distinction between Harry Potter and works with a "clear morality," implying that the way moral issues are handled differs significantly.
Alternative Viewpoints (Not Present in Reference)
It's important to note that this specific reference provides a strong negative stance based on perceived moral ambiguity. Other viewpoints might focus on:
- Age Ratings: Official movie ratings (e.g., PG) are determined by various factors, including fantasy violence, scary moments, and thematic elements.
- Individual Child Sensitivity: What is appropriate varies greatly depending on a child's maturity, fears, and understanding.
However, strictly following the provided reference, the conclusion is that the film is inappropriate for most and for children without a strong moral compass.
Summary of Concern from Reference
The primary concern is that the series, including the first film, may not provide a sufficiently clear or positive moral framework for young, developing minds, contrasting it unfavorably with other fantasy works. This leads to the strong caution against showing it to minors, especially those whose morality is not yet robustly formed.
