It's generally not recommended to use spreadable butter (tub butter) for making cookies.
While you can use it in a pinch, the results often won't be as good as if you used stick butter. The key difference lies in the fat and water content.
Why Stick Butter is Preferred for Cookies
-
Higher Fat Content: Stick butter, especially unsalted stick butter, has a higher fat content than spreadable butter. Fat is crucial for creating tender, flavorful cookies.
-
Lower Water Content: Spreadable butter has added water to make it softer and easier to spread at refrigeration temperatures. This extra water can negatively impact the texture of your cookies.
The Impact of Spreadable Butter on Cookies
Using spreadable butter can lead to:
- Dry Cookies: The excess water can evaporate during baking, leaving the cookies dry and crumbly.
- Tough Cookies: Increased gluten development due to the water can result in tougher cookies.
- Soggy Cookies: Sometimes, the water can prevent the cookies from crisping up properly, resulting in a soggy texture.
- Cookies That Spread Too Thin: The extra water and altered fat content can cause cookies to spread excessively during baking, resulting in thin, flat cookies.
- Altered Flavor: The added ingredients in some spreadable butters can also affect the overall flavor of your cookies.
What if You Only Have Spreadable Butter?
If you only have spreadable butter, you can try to minimize the negative effects by:
- Reducing the Liquid in the Recipe: Slightly reducing the amount of liquid (e.g., milk, water) in the recipe can help compensate for the extra water in the butter. Start with a small reduction (1-2 tablespoons) and adjust as needed.
- Chilling the Dough: Chill the dough thoroughly before baking. This can help to prevent excessive spreading.
- Using a Higher Oven Temperature: A slightly higher oven temperature can help the cookies crisp up faster, reducing the chances of them becoming soggy.
- Expect some texture changes: Don't expect the same level of perfection from the cookie recipe.
Best Butter for Cookies
For the best cookie results, use:
- Unsalted Stick Butter: Allows you to control the salt level in your recipe. Ensure it's cold, or softened, as your recipe calls for.
- European-Style Butter: Higher fat content than standard stick butter, which can result in richer, more flavorful cookies.
