Fair dealing criticism is the use of copyright-protected material for the specific purpose of critique or review, without requiring permission from the copyright holder, provided the use is considered "fair."
Here's a more detailed breakdown:
-
Foundation in Copyright Law: Fair dealing is an exception to copyright infringement, allowing specific uses of copyrighted works without permission. This is balanced against the copyright holder's rights.
-
Purpose: Criticism and Review: The key element of "fair dealing criticism" is that the copyrighted work is being used for the genuine purpose of critique or review. This could include analysis, commentary, or assessment of the work itself or its broader implications.
-
"Fairness" is Key: Whether a use is considered "fair" is determined on a case-by-case basis. Various factors are considered by courts, including:
- The purpose and character of the dealing: Is it truly for criticism or review, or is it simply copying for commercial gain?
- The nature of the copyrighted work: Is it a factual work, which may allow for more liberal use, or a highly creative work?
- The amount and substantiality of the portion dealt with: How much of the original work is being used? Is it only the portion necessary for the criticism? Using the "heart" of the work may be less likely to be considered fair.
- The effect of the dealing on the market for the copyrighted work: Does the use harm the potential market or value of the original work?
-
Attribution is Crucial: Even if the use qualifies as fair dealing criticism, proper attribution of the original work is generally expected and often legally required. This includes citing the author, title, and source of the material being used.
-
Examples:
- A film critic using short clips from a movie to illustrate their points in a review.
- A book reviewer quoting passages from a novel to support their analysis of the author's style.
- An academic using excerpts from a research paper to critique its methodology.
-
Distinction from Parody/Satire: While related, fair dealing for criticism differs from fair dealing for parody or satire. Criticism aims to analyze or evaluate the original work, while parody or satire uses the original work for humorous or critical commentary that is distinct from the original work itself.
-
Legal Nuances: The specific laws and interpretations of "fair dealing" vary by country. Always consult the relevant copyright legislation for the specific jurisdiction.
In conclusion, fair dealing criticism is a legal exception that allows the use of copyrighted material for critique and review, provided that the use is genuinely for that purpose, it meets the "fairness" criteria, and proper attribution is given.
