Growing crystals directly on limestone, in the way one might grow sugar crystals on a string, is generally not feasible because limestone will dissolve in solutions typically used to grow crystals. However, you can induce crystal growth around limestone. The process described below will not create large, defined crystals ON the limestone, but rather potentially encourage smaller mineral formations on or near the rock. The key is controlled evaporation of the solution.
Steps to (Attempt) Crystal Growth Near Limestone:
Here's a modified approach, based on the reference and understanding the properties of limestone (calcium carbonate), to attempt crystal formation around your limestone sample:
-
Clean the Limestone: Gently clean your limestone sample to remove any loose dirt or debris. Avoid harsh chemicals that might damage the rock. Water and a soft brush should suffice. Let it dry completely.
-
Choose Your Crystal-Forming Substance: Given that limestone will react with vinegar (acetic acid), which the provided reference mentions, the opposite effect of growing crystals will occur – the limestone will dissolve. To encourage crystal growth (of a different mineral), consider using a saturated solution of borax (sodium borate), alum (potassium aluminum sulfate), or even table salt (sodium chloride). These are less reactive with the limestone itself. Important Note: Growing different crystals around the limestone may result in very small crystals, if any at all. It will be an experiment.
-
Prepare a Saturated Solution: For example, to create a borax solution:
- Heat distilled water (this helps more borax dissolve).
- Gradually add borax powder to the hot water, stirring continuously.
- Continue adding borax until no more will dissolve, even with stirring. Some powder will settle at the bottom. This indicates a saturated solution.
- Let the solution cool slightly.
-
Submerge the Limestone: Place your limestone sample in a clean container (glass or plastic). Carefully pour the slightly cooled, saturated solution over the limestone until the rock is mostly submerged, but perhaps with a portion exposed to air. Avoid getting any undissolved solids from the bottom of the solution into your container.
-
Controlled Evaporation: This is crucial. Place the container in a location where it will not be disturbed. A windowsill is fine, but protect it from drafts. Allow the water to evaporate slowly over several days or weeks. As the water evaporates, the solution will become more concentrated, and crystals may begin to form on the limestone and/or around the edges of the container.
-
Observation and Patience: Observe the container daily. You may see small crystal formations developing. Avoid disturbing the process. The slower the evaporation, the larger the potential crystal size.
Important Considerations:
- Limestone's Reactivity: Remember that limestone is primarily calcium carbonate (CaCO3) and is reactive with acids. Avoid acidic solutions.
- Crystal Type: The type of crystal that might grow depends entirely on the substance you dissolved in the water (borax, alum, salt, etc.).
- Success Not Guaranteed: This is an experiment, and there's no guarantee you'll get large, well-defined crystals. Environmental factors, the purity of your materials, and the rate of evaporation all play a role.
- Safety: Always wear appropriate safety glasses and gloves when working with chemicals like borax or alum. Keep out of reach of children and pets.
Why the Original Reference (vinegar) Is Incorrect:
The original reference suggesting vinegar would dissolve the limestone due to the acetic acid, preventing any crystal growth on the stone. You might get some calcium acetate crystals in the solution, but they wouldn't form on the limestone; the limestone itself would be broken down.
