You change interrogative sentences into indirect speech by altering the reporting verb, using an appropriate connector (like 'if', 'whether', or the question word itself), and changing the sentence structure from a question to a statement.
Changing a direct question into an indirect statement requires several key transformations. These changes ensure that the sentence is grammatically correct in its new form and accurately reflects the original meaning without being a direct quote.
According to the provided reference and standard grammar rules, here are the primary steps involved:
Key Rules for Conversion
-
Change the Reporting Verb: The reporting verb "said" or "said to" is typically changed to a verb that indicates questioning or inquiry.
- According to the reference: The reporting verb "said to" is changed into "asked".
- Other common options include inquired, wondered, demanded, etc., depending on the context.
-
Use an Appropriate Connector: The comma and inverted commas from direct speech are removed, and a connector is used to introduce the indirect question.
- For Yes/No Questions: If the direct question can be answered with "yes" or "no" (usually starting with an auxiliary verb like is, are, was, were, has, have, had, do, does, did, or a modal verb like can, could, will, would, shall, should, may, might), you use "if" or "whether" as the connector. This aligns with the reference's point: "If reporting speech is having reporting verb at it its start, then if is used in place of that" (interpreted as using "if" in place of the declarative connector "that" when the direct speech starts with a verb, indicating a Yes/No question).
- For Wh-Questions: If the direct question starts with a question word (Who, What, Where, When, Why, How), that same Wh-word acts as the connector in the indirect speech.
-
Change Sentence Structure: The indirect question takes the form of a statement (assertive sentence), not a question.
- The word order changes from verb + subject to subject + verb.
- The question mark (?) at the end of the direct question is replaced by a full stop (.).
-
Apply Other Standard Changes: As with converting declarative sentences, you also typically need to adjust:
- Pronouns: Change pronouns to reflect the new perspective (e.g., "I" becomes "he" or "she," "you" becomes "I," "he," "she," "they," etc.).
- Tenses: Shift the tense backward (e.g., simple present to simple past, present continuous to past continuous, simple past to past perfect, etc.).
- Time and Place References: Change words indicating proximity (e.g., "now" to "then," "here" to "there," "today" to "that day," "tomorrow" to "the next day").
Summary Table of Key Changes
Here's a quick look at the core transformations:
| Aspect | Direct Speech (Interrogative) | Indirect Speech (Statement) |
|---|---|---|
| Reporting Verb | said / said to | asked / inquired / wondered, etc. |
| Connector | (None before the question) | if / whether (for Yes/No) or Wh-word |
| Sentence Structure | Question word order (Verb+Subject) | Statement word order (Subject+Verb) |
| Punctuation | Question mark (?) | Full stop (.) |
| Other Changes | Pronoun, Tense, Time/Place (Adjusted) | Pronoun, Tense, Time/Place (Shifted appropriately) |
Examples
Let's see how these rules work in practice:
-
Yes/No Question:
- Direct: He said to me, "Are you busy?"
- Indirect: He asked me if I was busy.
- (Explanation: "said to" changed to "asked," "Are you..." (Yes/No) uses "if," structure changed to "I was" (Subject+Verb), tense changed from present "Are" to past "was", pronoun "you" changed to "I").
-
Wh-Question:
- Direct: She said, "Where is the book?"
- Indirect: She asked where the book was.
- (Explanation: "said" changed to "asked," "Where" (Wh-word) is used as the connector, structure changed to "the book was", tense changed from present "is" to past "was").
By following these steps, you can effectively convert direct interrogative sentences into indirect speech, maintaining clarity and grammatical correctness.
