Teaching embedded questions in ESL involves explaining their structure and purpose, focusing on key grammatical transformations from direct questions.
Teaching embedded questions in English as a Second Language (ESL) focuses on understanding their function in making questions more polite or indirect, and mastering the specific grammatical changes required.
Embedded questions are questions placed inside another sentence or question. They often start with phrases like "Do you know...", "I wonder...", "Could you tell me...", or "I'd like to know...".
Here are the key steps and rules for teaching embedded questions, incorporating essential points:
Key Rules for Forming Embedded Questions
When transforming a direct question into an embedded question, specific structural changes are necessary. The primary changes involve word order and the handling of auxiliary verbs.
-
Use Statement Word Order: This is the most crucial rule. Unlike direct questions which use question word order (often auxiliary verb + subject + main verb), embedded questions follow the order of a statement: Subject + Verb.
- Direct Question: Where does he live?
- Embedded Question: Do you know where he lives? (Subject 'he', Verb 'lives')
- Direct Question: What are they doing?
- Embedded Question: I wonder what they are doing. (Subject 'they', Verb 'are doing')
-
Delete the Helping Verb 'Do/Does/Did' from the Original Question: When 'do', 'does', or 'did' is used as a helping verb in the direct question, it is removed in the embedded form. The main verb must then be adjusted based on the subject and tense.
- Direct Question: When do they eat? (Remove 'do')
- Embedded Question: Could you tell me when they eat?
- Direct Question: How much does it cost? (Remove 'does', add '-s' to the main verb)
- Embedded Question: I'd like to know how much it costs.
- Direct Question: Why did she leave? (Remove 'did', change main verb to past tense)
- Embedded Question: Do you know why she left?
-
For Yes/No Questions, Add 'If/Whether': If the original question is a yes/no question (one that can be answered with 'yes' or 'no' and doesn't start with a 'wh-' word), you must introduce the embedded question with the word 'if' or 'whether'.
- Direct Question: Is he coming?
- Embedded Question: I wonder if he is coming. (Or whether he is coming.)
- Direct Question: Can she swim?
- Embedded Question: Do you know if she can swim? (Or whether she can swim.)
- Direct Question: Did they finish? (Remove 'did')
- Embedded Question: Could you tell me if they finished? (Or whether they finished.)
Comparing Direct and Embedded Questions
A table can be a helpful visual aid for students to see the transformation.
| Feature | Direct Question | Embedded Question |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Direct inquiry | More polite/indirect inquiry |
| Structure | Question word order | Statement word order (Subject + Verb) |
| Helping Verbs | Uses do/does/did (often) | Removes do/does/did |
| Yes/No Qs | Starts with auxiliary verb | Uses 'if' or 'whether' |
| Ending | Usually ends with a question mark (?) if the main clause is a question | Ends with ? (if main clause is a Q) or . (if main clause is a statement) |
Practical Teaching Strategies
- Start Simple: Begin with embedded questions introduced by simple phrases like "Do you know...?" or "I wonder...".
- Practice Transformations: Give students direct questions and have them rewrite them as embedded questions using various introductory phrases.
- Focus on Word Order: Provide exercises specifically targeting the Subject + Verb order after the question word (or 'if'/'whether'). Scramble sentences for students to reorder correctly.
- Highlight 'Do/Does/Did' Removal: Dedicate practice to questions using these auxiliaries, ensuring students remember to remove them and adjust the main verb's form.
- Use Real-Life Scenarios: Role-play situations where embedded questions are naturally used, such as asking for information politely in a shop or asking a friend about someone else.
- Error Correction: Point out common errors, like using question word order or failing to remove 'do/does/did', and guide students to self-correct.
By focusing on these core rules and providing ample practice, ESL learners can effectively learn to form and use embedded questions correctly.
