No, fish sauce is not a direct substitute for fish stock, although it can sometimes contribute to a similar umami flavor profile. They are distinct products with different properties and uses.
Understanding the Differences
-
Fish Stock: Fish stock is a flavorful broth made by simmering fish bones, scraps, and aromatics (like vegetables and herbs) in water. It's typically light in color and possesses a delicate, savory flavor. Its main purpose is to add depth and richness to dishes. The reference from Primal Edge Health highlights the use of fish broth (similar to stock) as a base for sauces and veloutés.
-
Fish Sauce: Fish sauce is a fermented condiment made from fish and salt. It has a strong, pungent aroma and a salty, umami-rich flavor. It is used as a seasoning agent to enhance the taste of dishes, adding savoriness and complexity. The Reddit discussion in r/theregulationpod clearly states this difference: Stock is made from boiled fish parts, while fish sauce is fermented fish.
When Fish Sauce Might Be Used
While not a replacement, fish sauce can supplement or partially mimic some aspects of fish stock. Several references support this:
- Adding Umami: A reference mentions using fish sauce or soy sauce for darker stock, indicating its role in enhancing savoriness.
- Partial Substitution: Some sources suggest using a small amount of fish sauce mixed with water as a substitute, acknowledging that it won't perfectly replicate the delicate flavor of fish stock, but will provide a similar salty component. Eat Your Beets provides this example. This is especially helpful when a recipe calls for a small amount of fish stock. However, the significant difference in taste must be noted. In the r/AskCulinary discussion, the poster noted that using fish sauce in chicken stock will add savouriness and a slight tang, but not replicate the subtle flavor.
Conclusion
While fish sauce can add umami and saltiness, it's crucial to understand that it is not a true substitute for fish stock. They differ significantly in their production methods, resulting in distinct flavor profiles and culinary applications. Using fish sauce in place of fish stock will alter the dish’s overall character.
