Coal and coal seam gas (CSG) are both related to coal deposits, but they are fundamentally different. Coal is a solid fossil fuel, while coal seam gas is a natural gas, primarily methane, trapped within coal seams.
Key Differences Between Coal and Coal Seam Gas
Here's a breakdown of the key differences:
-
State of Matter: Coal is a solid, while coal seam gas is a gas.
-
Composition: Coal is a complex mixture of carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen, and sulfur. Coal seam gas is primarily methane (CH4) with trace amounts of other gases.
-
Location and Formation: Coal is formed from accumulated plant matter over millions of years under heat and pressure. Coal seam gas is generated during the coalification process and becomes trapped within the coal seams.
-
Extraction Methods: Coal is extracted through mining, either surface (open-pit) or underground. Coal seam gas is extracted by drilling wells into the coal seam and pumping out the water, which reduces pressure and allows the gas to be released from the coal.
-
How it is Trapped: Coal forms a solid matrix. CSG adheres to the surface of coal particles within the coal seams; water pressure keeps it in place until extraction.
Detailed Comparison
| Feature | Coal | Coal Seam Gas (CSG) |
|---|---|---|
| State | Solid | Gas |
| Main Component | Carbon | Methane (CH4) |
| Formation | Plant matter compressed over millions of years | Generated during coalification, trapped within coal seams |
| Extraction | Mining (surface or underground) | Drilling wells and reducing water pressure |
| Use | Electricity generation, steel production, heating | Electricity generation, heating, industrial processes, feedstock for chemicals |
Importance of Water Pressure in CSG Extraction
The presence of water within the coal seams is crucial to how CSG is trapped. The water pressure keeps the methane adsorbed onto the coal surface. To extract the gas, this water is pumped out, lowering the pressure and allowing the methane to desorb from the coal and flow to the well. This process often generates large volumes of produced water that requires treatment and disposal.
Environmental Considerations
Both coal mining and CSG extraction have environmental impacts. Coal mining can lead to habitat destruction, water pollution, and air pollution. CSG extraction can also impact water resources and contribute to greenhouse gas emissions if methane leaks occur during the process.
