According to the Quanta Magazine explainer featuring Vijay Balasubramanian, a physicist at the University of Pennsylvania, the biggest problem in physics centers around understanding the nature of space-time and its potential limitations.
The Challenge of Space-Time
The current understanding of space-time, while successful in many areas, is failing to explain certain phenomena and may not represent the deepest level of reality. Balasubramanian takes us through this journey to investigate what space-time is made of, why it's failing us, and where physics can go next.
Why is Space-Time Problematic?
-
Incomplete Picture: The theory of space-time, which is the foundation of Einstein's theory of general relativity, describes gravity as the curvature of space-time. This model works exceptionally well for describing large-scale phenomena like the motion of planets and the expansion of the universe. However, it clashes with quantum mechanics, which governs the behavior of matter at the atomic and subatomic levels.
-
Singularities: General relativity predicts the existence of singularities, points in space-time where the curvature becomes infinite and the laws of physics break down. These singularities occur inside black holes and at the Big Bang, the beginning of the universe. The presence of singularities suggests that general relativity is incomplete and needs to be modified or replaced by a more fundamental theory.
-
Quantum Gravity: A key challenge is developing a theory of quantum gravity that can reconcile general relativity with quantum mechanics. Attempts to quantize gravity using standard methods have led to inconsistencies and infinities, indicating that a new approach is needed. String theory and loop quantum gravity are two prominent candidates for a theory of quantum gravity, but both face significant challenges.
What's Next for Physics?
Balasubramanian's exploration suggests a potential path forward:
-
Emergent Space-Time: Some physicists propose that space-time may not be fundamental but rather emergent, arising from the collective behavior of more fundamental constituents. This is similar to how the properties of a fluid emerge from the interactions of its individual molecules.
-
New Theoretical Frameworks: The search for a deeper understanding of reality may require developing new theoretical frameworks that go beyond our current understanding of space-time. This could involve exploring alternative mathematical structures and physical principles.
-
Experimental Tests: While theoretical progress is crucial, experimental tests are also needed to guide the development of new theories. This could involve searching for subtle effects predicted by quantum gravity theories or exploring the properties of black holes and the early universe.
