askvity

Can We Talk to a Dead Person in Islam?

Published in Islamic Afterlife 2 mins read

No, according to Islamic scholars, you cannot communicate with deceased individuals while you are awake. This is a consensus view among Islamic scholars. Attempts to communicate with the dead are considered impermissible.

Understanding Islamic Views on Communication with the Deceased

Several sources explicitly state the impossibility of communicating with the dead. One source asserts that anyone claiming otherwise is either lying or requires medical attention. This statement highlights the firm stance against such communication.

The Quran itself provides a verse interpreted as evidence against communication with the dead: "You cannot make the dead hear." (Quran 27:88). This verse is often cited to support the Islamic view on this matter. This interpretation can be found here.

While Islamic teachings permit visiting graves and offering prayers (dua) for the deceased, direct communication is explicitly forbidden. This distinction is clarified here. The prescribed practice is to greet the deceased with a salutation (Salam) and to pray for their well-being, not to engage in a conversation.

The fear that attempting to communicate with the deceased might lead to Shirk (associating partners with God) is also a significant concern. This concern is discussed here.

Furthermore, claims of communication with the deceased through mediums or psychics are rejected within Islam. Such claims are addressed here. These practices are considered forbidden due to their potential to lead to misguidance and falsehood. This is a unanimous scholarly agreement. Note that while dreams might feature deceased loved ones, this is different from direct communication while awake.

In summary: Islamic teachings strictly prohibit attempts to communicate with deceased individuals while awake. The focus instead is on remembering them through prayer and maintaining a proper understanding of the afterlife.

Related Articles