Wearing clothing that is pure red is considered haram (forbidden) for men in some interpretations of Islamic law. This prohibition stems from reports that the Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him) disliked garments dyed with safflower, a red dye. However, this dislike doesn't extend to all red garments, and the permissibility often hinges on the shade of red and whether it's mixed with other colors.
Different Interpretations and Perspectives
The Islamic rulings on wearing red are not universally agreed upon. Different schools of thought and scholars offer varying interpretations:
-
Prohibition of pure red for men: Several sources indicate that wearing pure, undiluted red is discouraged or forbidden for men. This is often linked to the Prophet's dislike of safflower dye and interpretations focusing on avoiding ostentatious displays of color. Examples include mentions in Reddit discussions (https://www.reddit.com/r/islam/comments/195fcxc/ruling_on_wearing_red/) and tweets by scholars (https://twitter.com/Assimalhakeem/status/1134988357401010176).
-
Permissibility of red mixed with other colors: Many sources clarify that the prohibition doesn't apply to red clothing if it's combined with other colors. The key is to avoid the pure or plain red associated with the disliked safflower dye. This point is highlighted in IslamQA (https://islamqa.info/en/answers/8341/is-wearing-red-haram-in-islam).
-
Differing opinions on women: While the prohibition mainly applies to men, sources indicate differing opinions regarding women wearing red. Some interpretations suggest it's permissible, while others advise considering cultural norms and avoiding excessive displays. IslamQA provides insight into the Hanafi school of thought on this (https://islamqa.org/hanafi/qibla-hanafi/42618/women-in-red-is-wearing-red-impermissible-for-women-5/).
Key Considerations
-
The type of red: The prohibition largely focuses on intense, bright red colors associated with safflower dye. Deeper or more muted shades might not fall under the same restrictions.
-
Cultural context: Social norms and traditions in different Islamic communities may influence the interpretation and application of this ruling.
-
Scholarly consensus: There's no single, universally accepted interpretation across all Islamic schools of thought. Consulting knowledgeable scholars within one's tradition is advised for personal guidance.
According to the provided references, the prohibition of red clothing applies primarily to men wearing pure, undiluted red, often associated with safflower dye. The permissibility changes when red is combined with other colors. The ruling for women varies depending on the school of thought.
