The permissibility of a husband drinking his wife's milk in Islam is a complex issue with varying opinions. While some sources state it's permissible, others deem it undesirable or even haram (forbidden).
Permissible Views:
Several sources suggest that drinking a wife's milk is permissible and has no effect on the marital relationship. This is supported by statements from Daruliftaa.com, headed by Mufti Muhammad ibn Adam Al-Kawthari, who states that "drinking the wife's milk has no effect on the marriage." Some Shia scholars also hold this view. The consensus among these sources is that the act itself does not invalidate the marriage or create any additional familial relationships.
- Argument: The act of breastfeeding that creates a mahram (close relative) relationship requires a significant amount of milk consumption to be considered religiously relevant. A small amount of milk from the wife would not constitute that same significance.
Undesirable or Haram Views:
Other sources express that while not strictly prohibited, the act is considered undesirable or even haram. Some argue that it is abnormal and not in keeping with societal norms. Concerns about hygiene or the potential for creating a religiously-significant relationship through minimal breastfeeding are often raised. This view emphasizes a conservative approach to interpretation and a caution against potentially questionable practices.
- Argument: The act may be considered unhygienic or inappropriate due to potential microbial transmission, and the idea of it being contrary to customary practices within Islamic culture.
Conclusion:
The permissibility of a husband drinking his wife's milk in Islam remains a matter of differing interpretations. While some Islamic scholars find it permissible, others caution against it due to its perceived unusual nature or potential hygienic concerns. The act's effect on the marital relationship, according to many, is negligible.
