In Islam, the permissibility of another woman seeing your breasts depends on the context of the relationship between the women and interpretations of Islamic texts regarding awrah (parts of the body that should be covered).
Islamic teachings specify different levels of modesty depending on the relationship between individuals. The awrah between Muslim women is a topic with varying interpretations.
Interpretations of Awrah Between Women:
There are different scholarly opinions regarding the extent of awrah between Muslim women:
-
Navel to Knee: Some scholars believe that the awrah between Muslim women is the same as between men, which is from the navel to the knee. According to this view, seeing another woman's breasts would not be permissible except in cases of necessity (e.g., medical examination or treatment). This interpretation aligns with the reference provided.
-
Greater Freedom, but with Modesty: Other scholars permit Muslim women to expose more of their bodies to each other, as long as modesty is maintained and there is no risk of temptation or illicit behavior. However, even within this view, excessive exposure is generally discouraged.
-
Specific Scenarios: Some scholars differentiate based on the relationship between the women (e.g., close family members versus acquaintances) and the setting (e.g., at home versus in a public setting like a swimming pool).
General Guidelines:
Regardless of the specific interpretation, some general principles apply:
- Modesty is Paramount: Islam emphasizes modesty in all aspects of life, including dress and interaction between people.
- Intent Matters: The intention behind exposing or viewing the body is important. If there is any intention to cause temptation or harm, it is generally prohibited.
- Context is Key: The specific circumstances and the relationships between the women involved are crucial factors in determining what is permissible.
- Following Local Customs: It is advisable to consider and respect local customs and norms related to modesty.
Practical Implications:
This means that depending on which interpretation one follows, and the cultural context, the answer to whether another woman can see your breasts varies. In some interpretations and cultures, it's more acceptable among close family members in private settings, whereas in others it's discouraged.
Consultation with a Scholar:
Given the different interpretations, it's best to consult with a knowledgeable Islamic scholar to understand the specific guidelines and principles applicable to your situation and cultural context.
