Whether a man bun is haram (forbidden) in Islam is a subject of debate and depends on interpretation. The core concern revolves around whether the hairstyle imitates women or non-believers, or violates principles of modesty.
Here's a breakdown:
- General Principle: In Islam, men are generally discouraged from imitating women in appearance. Additionally, Muslims should avoid imitating the styles of non-believers that are contrary to Islamic values.
- The "Camel Hump" Issue: Some scholars consider a high man bun, particularly one positioned at the very top of the head, to be problematic. This is because it may resemble the "camel hump" hairstyle that has been warned against for women, as it is seen as immodest. The reference you provided also touches upon this issue.
- Practical Considerations: If the man bun is neat, modest, and doesn't resemble female hairstyles of a specific culture or group that one is prohibited from imitating, it might be permissible for some. The cultural context in which the hairstyle is worn is important.
- Intention Matters: As with many aspects of Islamic life, intention plays a role. If the intention behind wearing a man bun is to imitate women or to attract undue attention in a way that is contrary to Islamic principles, it would likely be considered less acceptable.
In conclusion, there isn't a blanket "yes" or "no" answer. The permissibility of a man bun depends on its style, how it's perceived, the wearer's intention, and the cultural context. A low bun that doesn't resemble female hairstyles or the "camel hump" and is worn with modest intentions is more likely to be considered permissible than a high, ostentatious bun worn with questionable intentions. It's always best to consult with a knowledgeable and trusted Islamic scholar for personalized guidance.
