The answer is that some scholars consider ear piercing for men to be completely haram.
Here's a breakdown based on the provided reference:
Some scholars view ear piercing for men as forbidden (haram) because it is seen as an imitation of women. This viewpoint is based on the Islamic teaching that:
- Men should not imitate women in appearance or actions.
- The Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) has cursed those who do so.
Specifically, the reference states: "The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) cursed men who imitate women and women who imitate men.” This hadith is used to discourage any behavior that is perceived as belonging to the opposite gender.
| Aspect | View of Some Scholars |
|---|---|
| Ear Piercing for Men | Completely Haram |
| Reasoning | Imitation of women, which is forbidden in Islam. |
Therefore, based on this referenced scholarly interpretation, ear piercing for men is **not permitted**. They believe it falls under the category of imitating the opposite gender, which is strictly prohibited in Islam.
