No, according to several Islamic sources, a mahram (close male relative) is not permitted to see a woman's breasts. While differing interpretations exist regarding the exact definition of awra (the parts of the body that must be covered), a significant number of Islamic scholars define the area between the navel and knees as the awra for women in front of their mahram. This excludes the chest and breasts.
However, some interpretations suggest that the permissible view for a mahram may be broader, depending on the context and intent. This can lead to differing opinions and practices within the Muslim community.
Understanding Contradictory Views
The varying opinions stem from different interpretations of Islamic texts and scholarly viewpoints. Some sources state that the awra is limited to the area between the navel and the knees, while others permit a broader view for mahrams, often excluding only the genitals. The crucial element to consider is the intent: Looking with lustful intent is always forbidden, regardless of the body part viewed.
Supporting Evidence:
-
Islamic Sources: Several Islamic websites and scholars agree that the breasts are not included in the area considered awra for women in front of mahram. IslamQA directly addresses this question, stating that the chest and breasts are not included in the awra in front of mahrams. The reference, 08-Dec-2021, explicitly states that "the chest including the breasts and the area parallel to the chest from the back are not considered to be part of the Awra of a slave-woman and a Mahram." Another source states that the mahram's permissible view is limited to parts commonly visible, such as the neck, but excludes the breasts Islamweb.net.
-
Contrasting Views: Some sources suggest a more lenient view, particularly regarding slave women in historical contexts, suggesting a mahram might see more of a woman's body Islam.stackexchange.com. These interpretations should be approached with caution and contextual understanding.
Conclusion:
While some interpretations allow for a broader range of permissible views for mahrams, a significant body of Islamic scholarship indicates that breasts are not considered permissible to be seen by mahrams. The intent behind the viewing remains a crucial factor in all interpretations.
