Whether it is haram (forbidden) to see a girl's breast depends on the context, particularly who is viewing and the circumstances involved, referencing the Islamic concept of awra.
Understanding Awra
Awra refers to the parts of the body that must be covered in the presence of those who are not mahram (non-related individuals whom marriage is permissible). The specific body parts that constitute awra vary based on gender and context.
Breast Exposure & Mahrams
Based on the provided reference, the following can be understood:
In conclusion, strictly speaking the breasts of a woman are not considered to be part of her Awra in the presence of her Mahrams, but the spirit of Shariah, religious propriety (adab) and local customs/norms (urf) require that she does not expose them unless there is a genuine need. 18-Sept-2006
This excerpt points out:
- Not Strictly Awra: In Islamic jurisprudence, a woman's breasts are not inherently considered awra in front of her mahrams. Mahrams include her husband, father, brothers, sons, etc., or individuals she is permanently forbidden to marry.
- Religious Propriety (Adab): Despite not being awra in this context, there is still an emphasis on adab, which encourages modesty and proper behavior. The exposure of breasts, even to mahrams, should not be done without a valid reason.
- Local Customs/Norms (Urf): Social norms and customs (urf) also influence what is considered acceptable behavior. In many cultures, it would be considered inappropriate to display the breasts even to mahrams without necessity.
- Need: If there is a genuine need (e.g., breastfeeding), then breast exposure to mahrams is permissible.
Summary Table
| Scenario | Haram? | Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| Seeing a girl's breast by a mahram | Generally No, but discouraged | Breasts are not considered awra for mahrams, but modesty and adab still apply. |
| Seeing a girl's breast by a non-mahram | Yes | The breasts are considered part of the awra, and it's prohibited to view them if you're not a mahram . |
| Breast exposure for breastfeeding | No | Considered permissible due to the legitimate need to nurse the child. |
Additional Considerations
- Intent: The intent behind looking also matters. If the view is unintentional or fleeting, it’s less problematic than staring or lustful gazing.
- Context: The context of the situation should be taken into account. What might be permissible in one context could be problematic in another.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while breasts are not strictly considered awra in the presence of mahrams, religious and cultural modesty dictate that exposure should be minimized and only happen when necessary. Seeing a girl's breast by a non-mahram would generally be considered haram.
