Lying on one's stomach is considered by some Islamic scholars to be makruh (disliked) or even haraam (forbidden), while others consider it permissible. There's no single, universally accepted ruling.
Different Perspectives on Sleeping Position in Islam
Several Hadith (sayings and traditions of the Prophet Muhammad) mention the disapproval of sleeping on one's stomach. These narrations state that this sleeping position is disliked by Allah or is characteristic of the people of Hell. Al-Iftaa Department, Abu Dawoud, Ibn Majah. However, the authenticity of these Hadith is debated among scholars. Some scholars consider the Hadith weak or inauthentic, leading to differing interpretations. Assim Alhakeem.
-
Scholarly Disagreement: The matter of sleeping on one's stomach is a controversial issue within Islamic jurisprudence. Some scholars classify it as makruh tahrimi (strongly disliked, approaching prohibition), while others see it as simply makruh tanzihi (lightly disliked, not prohibited) or even permissible. About Islam.
-
Emphasis on Right-Side Sleeping: Many Islamic sources strongly recommend sleeping on one's right side, citing both religious and health benefits. This is seen as a preferable posture. Quora.
-
Lack of Consensus: The absence of a definitive, universally agreed-upon ruling highlights the nuanced interpretations within Islamic scholarship. Individual interpretations and the strength given to specific Hadith vary amongst scholars. [Reddit (r/shia, r/islam)](https://www.reddit.com/r/shia/comments/1ah04us/is_lying_on_stomach_haram_like_in_sunnisim_it_is/, https://www.reddit.com/r/islam/comments/14z96aq/i_know_it_is_forbidden_to_sleep_on_your_stomach/)
-
Practical Considerations: While some consider it religiously undesirable, the severity of the prohibition remains a matter of individual interpretation and depends on the scholar's perspective on the Hadith's authenticity and its implications. Islamic Q&A, Islamic Board
Ultimately, the permissibility of lying on one's stomach in Islam remains a matter of scholarly debate and individual interpretation. It's advisable to consult with a knowledgeable scholar for personalized guidance.
