Based on interpretations focusing on preventing the flow of blood and lack of harm, using a menstrual cup can be considered permissible (halal).
According to a reference from 18-Feb-2021, "This indicates the permissibility of using means to prevent the blood from flowing to the outside. If the use of that cup serves this purpose and there is no fear of any potential harm, then there is nothing wrong with using it."
This statement provides a basis for understanding the permissibility of items like menstrual cups within Islamic guidelines concerning menstruation. The key aspects highlighted are:
Understanding the Permissibility
The permissibility hinges on two primary conditions derived from the reference:
- Preventing Blood Flow Outward: The primary function of a menstrual cup, like traditional methods, is to contain menstrual blood. The reference implies that using means to prevent the blood from flowing outside is acceptable. A menstrual cup effectively serves this purpose.
- Absence of Harm: The reference explicitly states that there should be "no fear of any potential harm" associated with its use. If a menstrual cup is used correctly and does not pose a health risk, this condition is met.
Why This Reasoning Matters
Islamic jurisprudence often considers the purpose and effect of an action or object. In the context of menstruation:
- Containing blood is necessary for hygiene and purification (though the woman remains in a state where she cannot perform certain acts of worship requiring purity).
- Methods that achieve this containment without causing harm are generally viewed favorably.
Practical Considerations
While the principle allows for the use, individuals should ensure these conditions are met:
- Correct Usage: Use the menstrual cup according to medical guidelines to avoid potential health issues.
- Hygiene: Maintain strict hygiene when inserting and removing the cup.
- Personal Comfort & Health: Discontinue use if it causes discomfort, pain, or other health concerns.
Therefore, if a menstrual cup is used safely and effectively contains menstrual blood, aligning with the criteria mentioned in the reference, it would fall under the category of permissible means.
