No, a wall generally cannot stop a major tsunami.
While walls, often referred to as seawalls, can offer some protection against smaller tsunami waves and coastal erosion, they are typically ineffective against large-scale tsunami events. Here's a breakdown:
-
Size Matters: Tsunami wave heights can reach tens of meters, dwarfing most seawalls. The reference highlights how the 19-foot seawall at the Fukushima nuclear plant was overwhelmed by a 40-foot wave during the 2011 Tohoku earthquake.
-
Energy and Momentum: Tsunamis possess immense energy and momentum. Even if a wall manages to initially deflect some of the water, the force can cause the wall to collapse, be overtopped, or cause erosion on the landward side.
-
Prolonged Flooding: The Fukushima example also demonstrated that walls can sometimes worsen the situation. While they might initially hold back some water, they can also prevent the water from receding quickly, leading to prolonged flooding.
-
Localized Protection: Seawalls can offer localized protection in specific areas, such as protecting critical infrastructure or densely populated zones from smaller waves or storm surges. However, they are not a complete solution for tsunami mitigation.
-
Comprehensive Mitigation Strategies: Effective tsunami mitigation involves a multi-faceted approach, including:
- Early warning systems: Detecting earthquakes and issuing timely warnings.
- Evacuation planning: Establishing clear evacuation routes and procedures.
- Land-use planning: Restricting development in high-risk areas.
- Coastal vegetation: Planting mangroves and other vegetation to provide natural buffers.
- Building codes: Enforcing stricter building codes in coastal areas to make structures more resistant to tsunami forces.
In conclusion, while seawalls can play a role in coastal defense, they are not a reliable way to stop a major tsunami and should be part of a broader, more comprehensive mitigation strategy.
