Singing while fasting is a complex issue with varying perspectives. The impact depends largely on the type of singing and the religious context of the fast.
Religious Perspectives
From a religious standpoint, specifically within Islam, singing while fasting may be considered undesirable (makrooh). While singing itself doesn't technically break a fast, it can detract from the spiritual purpose of the fast, particularly if the songs are secular in nature. One source states, "Singing a song technically will not break your fast. But it can spoil it, meaning it can damage the real purpose of your fast which is getting closer to Allah. This is why I believe this is Makrooh (undesirable) to sing a song while fasting. Especially if we are talking about worldly songs." Other religious traditions may have different views.
Physical Effects on Singing
Physically, fasting can impact vocal performance. Some singers report improved vocal quality during periods of fasting, potentially due to changes in hydration or lymphatic system function. However, other accounts describe negative impacts, such as increased morning vocal difficulty. One user noted, "It's worse in the AM, however it does impact me all day, especially when I try to sing in the evening." The effects seem to be individual and vary depending on factors like hydration levels and the length of the fast. The potential for a temporary extension of vocal range has also been suggested, with a claim that fasting, "cleans out the lymphatic system that runs right alongside of your neck, tonsils, voice box, chest, and head."
Conclusion
The question of whether it is bad to sing while fasting needs further clarification. The answer depends on the individual's religious beliefs and the potential physical impact on their vocal health. While it doesn't inherently break a religious fast, its appropriateness and potential benefits or drawbacks should be considered individually.
