The main difference lies in how they are extracted, which affects their composition, fragrance, and uses. While "rose oil" can be a general term, "rose essential oil" specifically refers to the product derived through a particular extraction method.
Essentially, rose essential oil is typically produced using steam or water distillation, whereas other forms of "rose oil," such as rose absolute or rose concrete, are obtained using solvent extraction methods.
Understanding the Terms
The term "rose oil" can sometimes be used as a catch-all phrase for any fragrant oil derived from roses. However, professionals and enthusiasts usually differentiate between the specific types based on their production process.
The two most common and distinct products referred to under the umbrella of "rose oil" are:
- Rose Essential Oil
- Rose Absolute (or Rose Concrete, which is an intermediate step before the absolute)
Extraction Methods: The Key Distinction
The method used to extract the fragrant compounds from rose petals is the primary factor distinguishing these products.
-
Rose Essential Oil Extraction
Rose essential oil is usually produced through steam or water distillation. This process involves passing steam through rose petals, which vaporizes the volatile fragrant compounds. The steam is then condensed back into liquid, and the oil separates from the water (known as rose hydrosol).
- Pros: Generally considered a pure essential oil suitable for aromatherapy.
- Cons: Requires a vast amount of petals to produce a small quantity of oil, making it very expensive. High heat can alter some delicate compounds.
-
Rose Absolute/Concrete Extraction
Rose absolute and concrete are produced using solvent extraction. This involves using a chemical solvent (like hexane) to dissolve the fragrant compounds from the petals, creating a waxy substance called a concrete. The concrete is then further processed with alcohol to remove the solvent and waxes, resulting in the liquid absolute.
- Pros: More efficient extraction captures a wider range of aromatic compounds, including some that are too delicate for distillation, often resulting in a scent closer to the fresh flower. Less plant material is needed compared to distillation.
- Cons: May contain trace amounts of residual solvent. Not typically recommended for internal use or therapeutic aromatherapy applications in the same way essential oils are.
According to the reference provided: "Absolutes and concretes use a solvent in the extraction process whereas essential oils are usually steam or water distilled." This confirms the fundamental difference in production methods.
Usage and Properties
The difference in extraction also impacts how these products are used and their properties.
-
Usage of Rose Essential Oil
Rose essential oil is used in both natural perfumery and for therapeutic aromatherapy purposes. Its composition is generally more focused on the volatile compounds effectively captured by distillation. It is highly valued for its potential emotional and skin benefits in aromatherapy.
-
Usage of Rose Absolute
Rose absolutes and concretes are generally used specifically in natural perfumery. Their richer, often sweeter, and more true-to-the-flower fragrance profile makes them highly prized by perfumers. While they possess beneficial properties, they are not typically the first choice for internal or broad therapeutic aromatherapy use due to the solvent extraction process.
As stated in the reference: "Rose absolutes and concretes are generally used in natural perfumery whereas rose essential oil can be used in both natural perfumery and for therapeutic aromatherapy purposes."
Summary Table
Here's a quick comparison of Rose Essential Oil and Rose Absolute:
| Feature | Rose Essential Oil | Rose Absolute / Concrete |
|---|---|---|
| Extraction | Steam or Water Distillation | Solvent Extraction |
| Composition | Volatile compounds from distillation | Wider range of compounds (including waxes) |
| Fragrance | Often classic rose scent, can be deep | Often richer, sweeter, more like fresh flower |
| Primary Use | Natural Perfumery, Therapeutic Aromatherapy | Natural Perfumery |
| Yield | Very low (requires vast petals) | Higher |
| Cost | Extremely high | High (often slightly less than EO) |
In conclusion, while "rose oil" might be a general term, the crucial distinction between rose essential oil and rose absolute/concrete lies in their extraction method (distillation vs. solvent extraction) and their typical usage (aromatherapy & perfumery vs. primarily perfumery).
