The answer is nuanced: it's not a simple choice of one over the other, but rather that both Aerith and Tifa play significant and different roles in Cloud's life and development.
Cloud doesn't explicitly choose one over the other in a traditional romantic "love triangle" scenario. The relationship dynamics are more complex and character-driven.
Here's a breakdown:
-
Aerith's Impact: Aerith's presence is vital for Cloud's personal growth. As stated in the reference, "Aerith is who Cloud needed at the point in his life when they met." She helps him confront his past and begin to heal from trauma related to Zack and his own identity confusion. Her influence allows him to become more emotionally available.
-
Tifa's Role: Tifa acts as Cloud's anchor. She is the consistent, supportive figure who helps him ground himself and reconnect with reality, particularly after Aerith's death. Tifa provides stability and a deep, unspoken understanding that stems from their shared history. The reference notes, "Cloud & Tifa don't get together if Aerith doesn't come into his life first."
-
The Importance of Both: It's important to understand that both women are crucial to Cloud's journey. Aerith helps him begin to heal, while Tifa helps him maintain that healing and build a future. It isn't about choosing; it's about understanding how both relationships shape him as a person.
In conclusion, Cloud's relationships with Aerith and Tifa are not mutually exclusive, but interconnected. Aerith helps him grow, and Tifa provides stability and companionship, ultimately leading to a deeper connection between Cloud and Tifa.
