Yes, you can upload a horizontal video to YouTube and have it function as a Short, based on user experiences.
While the standard and intended format for YouTube Shorts is vertical (a 9:16 aspect ratio), the platform's system allows users to upload videos with other dimensions, including horizontal ones (like 16:9). The provided reference explicitly mentions a creator trying and succeeding in creating a "horizontal" Short because their animation "just wasn't gonna fit in vertical."
Understanding YouTube Shorts Format
Typically, YouTube Shorts are designed for mobile viewing and are presented in a vertical, full-screen format. Key characteristics include:
- Aspect Ratio: Primarily 9:16 (vertical).
- Length: Up to 60 seconds.
- Discovery: Featured in the dedicated Shorts feed.
Uploading Horizontal Videos as Shorts
If you upload a horizontal video (e.g., 16:9 aspect ratio) that is 60 seconds or less and include #shorts in the title or description, YouTube's system may classify it as a Short.
What Happens When You Upload Horizontal?
When a horizontal video is viewed in the Shorts feed, YouTube displays it differently than a standard vertical Short.
- Black Bars: The video will typically appear with significant black bars above and below it to fill the vertical frame of the Shorts player.
- Viewing Experience: This can make the video appear small and may not provide the immersive, full-screen experience typical of vertical Shorts.
Here's a quick visual comparison:
| Feature | Standard Vertical Short (9:16) | Horizontal Video in Shorts Feed (16:9) |
|---|---|---|
| Aspect Ratio | Vertical | Horizontal |
| Display | Full screen (mobile) | Smaller frame with black bars |
| User Experience | Immersive | Potentially less engaging |
Why Would Someone Create a Horizontal Short?
As the reference suggests, practical reasons might lead someone to upload a horizontal video:
- Existing Content: Repurposing content originally created in a horizontal format (like the 4K animation mentioned).
- Specific Content Needs: Some visuals or actions might simply work better in a horizontal frame.
Practical Considerations
While technically possible, uploading horizontal videos as Shorts may impact performance and viewer engagement because they don't conform to the optimal viewing experience for the Shorts feed. Most creators aim for the vertical 9:16 format to maximize screen real estate and viewer immersion.
In summary, yes, you can upload a horizontal video as a YouTube Short, and it might appear in the Shorts feed, but it will be displayed with black bars and may not perform as well as a native vertical Short.
